Sword of the Stranger & the Dynamic Duality of Death – Anime Review

Please note: there will be spoilers for the film in this review, which will be marked when they appear. Read at your own discretion. Thank you.

Sword of the Stranger (ストレンヂア -無皇刃譚-) is an original anime film  that released in Fall 2007, was produced by studio BONES, and directed by Masahiro Andō. In all of my years of watching anime, I have never seen a more masterful and artistically brilliant cinematic title. Today, I want to share with you all of the reasons why you should watch this film if you haven’t already.

Sword of the Stranger takes place in Japan during the Sengoku Era (Age of Warring States, c. 1467 to c. 1568) and follows a young orphaned boy named Kotarō, and his doggie, Tobimaru, as they are being pursued by China’s Ming Dynasty warriors for unknown reasons. Along their journey, Kotarō and Tobimaru encounter Nanashi, an unnamed rōnin (master-less samurai warrior) who has vowed to never draw his sword again due to a dark and malevolent past. Through various plot happenings, Nanashi agrees to guide Kotarō and Tobimaru to a place of reprieve for the boy, thus building a deep bond along the way.

Sword 02

I am at a loss for where to begin with my review for this film because everything about it is so damn astounding. The premise, the animation (especially the action sequences), the music, the contemplative themes—all of them work together to complement and enhance one another to build a film that is quite a masterpiece, never overshadowing one element in lieu of the other. It is evocative, dark, and exquisitely revelatory of the era’s more twisted climates as well as human nature in general.

On the surface, Sword and the Stranger is about relationships and making amends. We have a young boy who has no parental figure or mentor in his life. It’s just him and his puppy against the blazing world. Then Nanashi enters the picture and shows the boy what it’s like to have that warmth that stems from having a father. A bond formulates between the two thanks to mindless bickering, lessons of horseback riding, and intimate revelations of each others’ melancholic past. Two deeply lonely individuals come to terms with the fact that they may no longer have to live like this anymore. A pure and basic story at its heart. However, this simplicity places a charming veil on a much more complicated notion that most people fear above all else: the inevitability of death.

** Spoilers ahead. **

Duality. This is my favourite thing about Sword of the Stranger. The consistent and multi-faceted exploration of the duality of death and what it means to be alive.

The Ming Dynasty warriors all take a special type of drug that renders them literally immune to pain and torture, thus allowing them to fight and fight and fight until they no longer draw breath. Only one character—Luo Lang—working on the Chinese soldier’s side, refuses to partake in the drug. He is someone who searches for that rush that you can only get by literally feeling everything around you, specifically in battle, which includes the knowledge that one could die at any given second. There is no feeling quite like the one you get when you are staring death in the fucking face. If you somehow manage to survive, then that rush of being truly alive can be unbelievably intoxicating. Numbing himself to this sensation is without question unacceptable and disrespectful the very essence of living.

Then you have Nanashi. All he wants it to feel numb, to forget his past; to find some black, ugly corner where he can go die. He doesn’t take drugs to stifle his pain and suffering as he does this via alienation and avoidance. Feeling alive is the absolute last thing that he desires in the world because then it makes the sins of his past real. It makes all of the wrongs he’s done a ghost that he cannot run away from, not that he ever stops trying.

This duality of death that you see here—one where the idea of death is exhilarating and the very essence of why someone should live to their fullest capacity, and one where the idea of it is a welcome escape—is everywhere in the film; softly woven into the conversations between Nanashi and Kotarō; slipped in between the battles that the mysterious Chinese soldier has with others, as well as the ones that Nanashi has with Kotarō’s pursuers; even forged into the swords that both characters fight with.

You see the duality outside of the two characters as well; a whisper in the overarching plot that’s never blatantly voiced, but assiduously implied. The Ming Warriors are sent on a mission that deals with a very twisted belief that the Chinese emperors of the dynasty were obsessed with—immortality—and this obsession was astoundingly anti-Confucian. During the Warring States period, within Confucianism death was viewed as something to be accepted and embraced, just as life was. If you didn’t understand how to live, you could never really understand what it means to die. Emperors were hell-bent on running away from death as much as they possibly could, thus defying this pivotal belief; a belief that their entire culture—at the time—and government was built upon.

Luo-Lang was the perfect encapsulation of the Confucian ideal of life and death while the Emperor that he worked for and the warriors that surrounded him were the epitome of anti-Confucian beliefs. He was very much the walking, talking, sword-fighting personification of the dual-nature of death during a time period that was passionately engrossed with everlasting authoritarianism; two sides of a single coin, as it were.

** End Spoilers. **

When you take all of the thematic elements into account—as there are quite a few that I haven’t even begun to mention here—while setting everything else aside for a moment, you will see that Sword of the Stranger is an amazing allegory for the struggles that both nations faced during the Warring States Era, particularly where the nuances of leadership and the impoverished people that became sacrifices for said leaders, are concerned. The wrongs of the king are never worth the blood shed by the peasants to propitiate those wrongs.

If there is anything that truly enhances the gloriously thought-provoking subject matter even further, then it is the phenomenal animation and production quality.

The film originally released in 2007, which was eleven years ago. Bones was doing fantastic work in terms of animation during this time, really testing out which limitations to push, and which ones weren’t up to par quite yet. With Sword of the Stranger, we are finally able to see their full potential as creators, as the film was one of the very first ones to utilise a seemingly flawless implementation of CGI graphics into hand-drawn cinematography to produce something that is sensationally fluid from one scene to the next, with vividly mind-blowing action sequences, character designs, and lush, splendidly detailed landscapes. From the opening scene, where rain and mud waltz in a flurry of defensive foot movements and swishing sword fighting, to the serenely calming scene where Kotarō and Nanashi are riding horseback through the shores of a beach amid a backdrop of the setting sunthe artistic execution is superbly stunning. Both sorts of cinematic scapes work to portray the traditional atmospheric aspects of Japanese chanbara film while also focusing on the key attribute that can make or a break an anime entirely: meticulous detail work.

The intricate focus on details is what ends up sealing the film’s beauty and raising it to the level of masterpiece. Close-ups of rain drops preparing to land upon the forehead of a dying soldier, the slight movements of straw as another character’s hat is sliced open, the gentle caress of the wind upon the bloodied fabric that holds Nanashi’s sword snuggly within its sheath—these minute aspects are layered one on top of another to formulate an effortlessly enthralling watching experience. It is damn difficult not be drawn in by the animation, given how stunning it is. The artistic value is further enhanced by the musical composition.

There isn’t a lot of heavy or consistent music in Sword of the Stranger, which is another facet that is akin to classic Japanese aesthetics, uniquely of classic literature. If you have ever read Haiku poems or anything by Bashō, these things will stand out to you almost instantly. It’s limited in quantity, but whenever it does make an appearance, it does so at pivotal plot points, such as when two warriors on the opposite sides of a horrible war finally meet so they can battle to a brutal demise , or when Kotarō and Nanashi hit a high note in their harmonising friendship. As an audience member, it really instilled within me an insidious build up of suspense and anticipation for the ultimate climax to come. It’s intelligently psychological and gorgeously moving, more so when you contemplate the deeper meanings portrayed beneath all of the simple elegance of family-hood and redemption.

All in all, there has never been an anime that has ever come close to being what Sword of the Stranger is: a perfect blending of excellent storytelling, complex characters, flawless animation and visual cinematography, superb melodic structure, and true-to-era exploration of the political climate. It is provocative, emotional, intellectually pensive, and one of the finest works of art that I have ever had the pleasure of experiencing in my life.

Native:  ストレンヂア 無皇刃譚
Source: Original
Demographic: Seinen
Genre: Chanbara, Supernatural
Season: Fall 2007
Episodes: Film
Studio: Bones
Director: Masahiro Andō
Content Warnings: Graphic violence, blood, and gore including dismemberment. Graphic depictions of starving people in poverty. Ritualistic killings and murder. Some strong language. Preparation and consumption of food. Mild drug use. Xenophobia. Governmental corruption. Death and injury to animals.
AniList: Stranger: Mukō Hadan
Streaming: Funimation, Anime Lab (Aus)

If you’d like to support BiblioNyan and help with future posts, please consider contributing a one-time donation of $3 via Ko-Fi. One-hundred-percent of the money goes towards the upkeep of BiblioNyan.

17 thoughts on “Sword of the Stranger & the Dynamic Duality of Death – Anime Review

  1. I am about half-way through it. I could only find the dub, so maybe not a perfect experience. It reminds me a bit of a spaghetti western. Sergio Leone took a lot of inspiration from traditional samurai stories, Kurasawa in particular.

      • The ronin and the gunslinger are very similar themes. “A Fistfull of Dollars” is a western copy of “Yojimbo.” “The Magnificent Seven” is a western copy of “The Seven Samurai.”

        • Never knew that about A Fistfull of Dollars. I never watched The Magnificent Seven because I figured it was a Western rip of Seven Samurai and wasn’t interested because of it. Seven Samurai is one of my favourite classic films of all time.

          • TM7 us cnsidered one of the best of all the westerns. It’s not a rip off because nobody in the US of the time would even be aware of the original let alone have seen it. Even if they did, most American’s would not fully appreciate it because they don’t understand Japanee culture. Settng it in the west makes it more approachable.

            It is a reimagining of the classic story, setting it in a small Mexccan village and adding in uniquely American elements. The soundtrack by Bernstein is nothing short of… magnificent.

            Guch…. gush… gush… gushing enthusiasm all over it.

            TM7 was popular enough that they made several really bad sequels. And then they genuinely ripped it off to create an obnoxious science fiction version. Even dragged Robert Vaughn out of retirement to have a tiny bit of cast continuity.

  2. Pingback: The Otakusphere: Wonder Egg, Dino King and can anyone stop Goku – In Search of Number Nine — An anime blog

  3. This has been on my list since 2007. I was suppose to see it in theaters but alas the drive wasn’t do-able so it got banished to the PTW. You’ve given me the push I’ve needed to hopefully watch this movie soon!

  4. YES!!! That’s what makes Sword/Stranger so fantastic: the themes. I actually never really considered the theme of duality. I always pondered the homage it plays to classical samurai films, mostly in the sense of redemption (which is the most obvious theme, lol), but also one of morality in the sense that there isn’t a real good and bad situation. Look at Luo Lang. He’s not really an antagonist, just a guy who’s looking for someone strong to cross swords with, someone who’ll make him feel alive. While he is following orders from a higher power, the Emperor, he doesn’t kill just for kicks. He’ll start a fight for kicks, but overall he’s such a neutral person. Then when those drugs wear off the Ming warriors, you see their humanity beginning to show as their numb facade starts to peel away. This humanity shows them as Luo: warriors following orders with no true allegiance to anything except a hierarchy that their disciplined from birth to oblige. It’s brilliant.

    Damn… I need to re-watch this film. Excellent fucking review. Loved it so much.

    • Hahaha, you’re such a nerd and I love you for it (look who’s talking, I know). YES!! He really isn’t an antagonist in the most traditional form, and it makes this film a masterpiece because it shows you don’t always have to have a “good” and “evil” character to make a story work; it doesn’t always have to be about “hero” and “villain” even if some of the inherent traits are there. Ah… this film deserves all the 10s, lol. Thanks for reading my review, cousin. Appreciate you. Mwah.

  5. Awesome review! This is one of those films I can put in and watch anytime and love it more than the last time. I never realized the theme of duality and life and death in the film but after reading over your review it makes a lot of sense! I’m gonna go watch it watch it later today! 😀

    • Yay!! Thank you, my friend! Yeah it really is a very interesting aspect of the film, probably my favourite one. 😃

  6. A wonderfully written piece on a wonderfully done film, I enjoyed watching this with you and agree full hearted with your takes on the different takes on duality, this film is a love letter to classic samurai films while also having it’s own unique voice. Thanks for sharing the film with me and this review with the world.

    • Yes!!! It most definitely is a love letter to classic samurai films, and that is a large part of the appeal. But as you said, it’s also original because it steps away from the common masterless samurai regaining his honour to shed light on a part of history that is rarely every discussed or explored. 🙂

  7. I don’t think I have ever had a week where I had to add so many things to my to read/to watch lists. I have never even heard of this movie but knowing you rarely give perfect scores, I now have to see this one for myself. Terrific post!! 😊😊

Comments are closed.